Random Thought on UI Benchmarking

If when showing off a new feature or device on a gadget to a friend you become embarrassed at how badly you've interrupted the flow of conversation, then the interface isn't yet fast enough.

I've been trying to think about ways to judge products beyond just "looks," "interface," and "battery life" benchmarks. "Conversation integration" is a step in the right direction, I think, if awkwardly phrased.


Discussion

Take a look at this

Or what about "Conversation Starter" for its social appeal, and "Conversation stopper" for how well its features can be shown off?

Take a look at this

It depends on the role of the UI. If the UI is meant to be peripheral that is a good criteria (being able to drive while using the UI is another one). On the other hand if the UI is immersive, it might be best if it utilized all cognitive resources.

Take a look at this

How about 'talk-through'?

Take a look at this

The showing of a device's features is a lot like selling it -- it's essentially an appeal to this person; a pitch. You could call it a tough sell or easy sell and I think a lot more people would understand what you mean. If I understand what you mean, anyway.

Take a look at this

@#4, Mike Overbo: Well, what you're talking is more back-filling than a pitch, with the tacit prefix "I'm not a moron for handing over an obscene sum of money for this gizmo because it does...".

However, it does make me wonder how many product features are designed with a view to the selling process rather than pure usability. For example, I have a Toshiba LCD TV which has a DNIe (some kind of dynamic noise reduction/contrast enhancing filter) button in a prominent position to the left of the zero button. You might imagine that this toggles DNIe on and off, but you'd be wrong: it toggles a split-screen demo of DNIe and nothing else.

Take a look at this

Man do I feel embarrassed. One of the last things I want to do is to visibly show off but that's exactly what I do with all the new gadgets I get my hands on. I can't even imagine how I'll be able to stop talking about the jesus phone if I ever get my hands on one...

Take a look at this

Imagine you were listening to a radio host tell a story that required a clip. Imagine that clip taking many tens of seconds to play, while the host pauses his story for power on and scroll to menu stuff. .... zzzz tune out ....

I know what you mean.

When I'm showing someone something, I want to be able to be ... punchy as John Stewart.

It would be fantastic if, during lunch, I could say "Hey, did you see that hilarious bit on last night's Daily Show about iraq?" and show it if they showed interest. Or, "hey, did you catch ... news/ American Idol performance/ whatever?" "Did you see what Senator Craig said?"

Did you see what Senator Craig sad .... wait wait ... wait for it. Okay, it's on. Scroll to vidoe, select title, play. "I am not gay. I love my wife..." takes too fracking long, man. Too long. You lose your audience.

Post a comment

Anonymous