David Pogue at the NYT was among the most blunt of those who slammed the Storm. The response, he writes, is denial from RIM itself and a hundred-ish letters in his mailbag from customers who agree with him. Here’s just one:
“I too find it unbelievable that these are for sale. Verizon should just box all these Storms up and send them to Toys R Us, who can sell them in the Brainteaser section, right next to the Rubik’s Cubes.”
About a dozen wrote in to disagree.
“Having you comment on technology is like having Tom Cruise comment on religion,”
That is, it must be said, a spicy rejoinder.
Here’s the interesting thing about all this: everyone has made touchscreen-only phones that would have seemed revolutionary were it not for the one they followed. But while the likes of Samsung’s Instinct and T-Mobile’s G1 can impress us by offering 80%, RIM can’t. RIM’s gear must always be more-or-less perfect, with only the slightest of give for price-range context. They are tools, and must perform the functions not just of a phone, but a BlackBerry, and anything less will only fail in sharper relief because of it.
Pogue’s col [NYT]